The 10% Rule: Should You Drop Your Comprehensive & Collision Insurance?

The 10% Rule: Should You Drop Your Comprehensive & Collision Insurance?

One of the most frequently asked questions about automobile insurance for those who own an older vehicle is when is it no longer economically wise to carry comprehensive collision coverage on that vehicle. For most, the 10% rule is a reasonable guideline. Here is how it works.

The 10% Rule Defined

The 10% rule is based on the premise that you should consider dropping your collision and comprehensive automobile insurance coverage when the cost of such coverage meets or exceeds 10% of the book value of the car. It sums that the MOST you can get to repair your vehicle is its book value so paying 10% or more for that protection provides diminishing returns.

Let’s take, for example, your vehicle has a book value of $5,000. Ten percent of this value would be $500. If the premium for the comprehensive collision coverage portion of your policy exceeds $500 annually, it is probably no longer a good value to maintain that coverage. You may be better off reducing coverage to just liability. Of course, it will depend on your tolerance for risks. You my also lose some other valuable protection by eliminating comprehensive collision coverage. It is best to ask your independent insurance agent how such a reduction will impact your coverage.

Why Minimum Coverage May Not Always Be Best

Understandably, most don’t want to pay any more than they have to for automobile insurance. This, like most things in life however, doesn’t necessarily mean you should get the cheapest or least expensive plan available. Just because states have minimum standards does not mean that may be sufficient for you. You may benefit considerably through the acquisition of under or uninsured motorist insurance, a rent-a-car provision when experiencing a loss of use or even higher minimums of overall coverage. This is particularly true for those who have more financial resources at risk.

One of the best solutions when you have questions about your automobile insurance coverage is to get an auto insurance review. If you prefer, your review can also include a quote from multiple insurance companies who compete for your business. This allows you to base your choice on value, not just price. Contact one of our independent insurance agents and get started today! Get the protection you need without overpaying for your automobile insurance.

Leave a Comment





Life Insurance: Why Waiting Limits Your Options

December 2, 2020

What You Need to Know About Today’s Driving Schools

December 1, 2020

Hurricanes, High Winds and Homeowners’ Insurance

November 30, 2020

The “Flying Nun” and Other Wild TV Show Premises

November 27, 2020

How to Get Clients to Promote Your Business

November 26, 2020

Five Cents a Week for Life Insurance? Wait…There’s more!

November 25, 2020

The Info You’ll Need to File an Automobile Insurance Claim

November 24, 2020

Buying a Home? See These Five Movies First

November 23, 2020

Six Women Who Made a Big Impact on Modern Music

November 20, 2020

Cutting Costs Without Slashing Your Business

November 19, 2020

The Difference Between Term Life Insurance and Permanent Life Insurance Explained

November 18, 2020

Preparing Your Home for a Natural Disaster

November 16, 2020

Steps to Better Secure Your Bricks and Mortar Business

November 12, 2020

A Closer Look at the Life Insurance Waiver of Premium Benefit

November 11, 2020

Why You Need to Document What Your Own

November 9, 2020

The Allure of the Great Smoky Mountains

November 6, 2020

Can I Buy Life Insurance if I’m Dying?

November 4, 2020

The Growing Problem of Aggressive Driving and Road Rage

November 3, 2020

College Life and Renters’ Insurance

November 2, 2020

Why Coin Collecting Is Still A Terrific and Educational Hobby for Kids

October 30, 2020

Why You Should Have an Annual Business Insurance Review

October 29, 2020

The Two Biggest Factors That Make Life Insurance Rates Increase

October 28, 2020

The Great Recreational Vehicle Revival

October 27, 2020

Want to Add Value to Your Home? Consider Upgrading Your Landscaping

October 26, 2020

Weird Stuff You May Not Know About Grocery Shopping

October 23, 2020

Tapping Into The Genius of Your Staff to Make Your Business Better

October 22, 2020

Life Insurance: Buy What You Can Afford

October 21, 2020

The 10% Rule: Should You Drop Your Comprehensive & Collision Insurance?

October 20, 2020

This Biggest Cause of House Fires May Surprise You

October 19, 2020

The Benefits of Downsizing Your Household

October 16, 2020

Five Cost-Effective Marketing Ideas for a Small Business

October 15, 2020

Why an Independent Agent is Your Best Option for Life Insurance Quotes

October 14, 2020

Six Common Sense Tips to Make Your Home Safer and More Secure

October 12, 2020

Seven Steps You Can Take Today to Gain Control of Your Household Budget

October 9, 2020

Five Facts About Small Business Insurance Most Aren’t Aware Of

October 8, 2020

Getting Married? Now’s a Good Time to Consider Life Insurance

October 7, 2020

Drivers Aside, Our Highways Are Getting Safer

October 6, 2020

The Five Most Common Home Insurance Liability Claims

October 5, 2020

8 Upgrades to Help You Sell Your Home Faster for More $

October 2, 2020

Why You Need Business Insurance Even if You Rent Your Business Space

October 1, 2020

Why Life Insurance Should Be a Fundamental Part of Your Financial Plan

September 30, 2020

The Ten Most Frequent Causes of Automobile Accidents

September 29, 2020

The Good, Bad and Ugly of Renting

September 28, 2020

Whatever Happened to These Rock Stars?

September 25, 2020

Etsy and Ebay and Work From Home Businesses

September 24, 2020

How States Determine If You Have Car Insurance

September 22, 2020

Are You Asking the Right Questions About Homeowners Insurance?

September 21, 2020

Smartphones: How and How Much We Use Them May Surprise You

September 18, 2020

Own a Rental? You May Need Business Insurance

September 17, 2020

What is Decreasing Term Life Insurance?

September 16, 2020

How States Determine If You Have Car Insurance

September 15, 2020

One of the Best Buys in Loss Prevention: Renters Insurance

September 14, 2020

Seven Steps to a Better Night’s Sleep

September 11, 2020

Checking for Financial “Leaks” at Your Business

September 10, 2020

Three Ways Life Insurance May Help Pay For College

September 9, 2020

Is Your Car Insurance Company Aware You are Driving for a Food Delivery or Ride Sharing Service?

September 8, 2020

How Average Are You? Compare With This 12 Point Checklist

September 4, 2020

Think Twice Before Cutting Back on Business Insurance

September 3, 2020

Life Insurance as a Gift

September 2, 2020

What You Should Know About High-Risk Car Insurance

September 1, 2020

Contact Us

-CONTACT US

OUR LOCATION

Have A Question?

We have an answer. Call us at 719-559-2544

719-559-2544

© Copyright 2020 Paramount Insurance Services  |   All Rights Reserved
Site by ICA Agency Alliance

719-559-2544

© Copyright 2020 Paramount Insurance Services  |   All Rights Reserved
Site by ICA Agency Alliance